Three apps were instanceable and the rest were silent, so the feature
looked far narrower than it is. Every app has now been checked against
the two rules instance_create.sh enforces, and the answer recorded in
its config rather than left unset.
32 apps are instance-safe and now say so. Six are not, and each says why
in its own words instead of being indistinguishable from an app nobody
had reviewed:
pihole a DNS server must own port 53
unbound a resolver must own its fixed 5335
stalwart a mail server must own 25/465/587/993
traefik must own 443, and one Traefik routes every other app
prometheus node-exporter and cadvisor carry no "prometheus" prefix
stoat pins 7881, and database/redis/rabbit/minio carry no prefix
The first four are genuinely one-per-host: the port is not arbitrary, it
is the protocol. The last two are compose-identity problems and could be
fixed by prefixing those service names, which is a change to make
deliberately rather than in passing.
Recorded as an explicit false with a reason, not left unset, so the next
person reads a decision instead of an absence. The audit was verified not
to pass anything vacuously: every app resolves at least one service name,
so no app reached "eligible" merely because nothing was found to check.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The only two templates in the catalogue shipping UPDATE_TYPE=manual,
and both rationales turn out not to apply to what auto actually does.
Automatic updates act on update_available, which is digest-based: they
apply a REBUILD of the tag an app already tracks and never cross a
version line. Crossing lines is the stepped Upgrade, which is a
deliberate action and stays one.
So Rocket.Chat, pinned to 8.7.0 with mongo 8.0, cannot be walked across
a major by the automatic path — the failure its comment guarded against
was unreachable. And Stoat's nine stoatchat services are all pinned to
the same tag, so a pull moves them together or not at all; they cannot
"roll forward independently" into an API/events mismatch.
What manual did cost was real: neither app picked up security rebuilds
of the version it was already on. Rocket.Chat is carrying a critical CVE
at the time of this change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Eleven app configs declared CFG_<APP>_AUTH_PROFILE as a "capability tier for the
WebUI auth tools". Nothing read it — not a shell script, not the frontend, and it
was never emitted into apps.json, so the WebUI could not have acted on it even in
principle.
The job it was meant to do is already done, and done better: authAdapterCanDo
tests `declare -F authAdapter_<app>_<method>`, so what an app can do is derived
from the functions it actually implements. A declared tier is a second source of
truth that can only drift — traefik declared single_password while its adapter
implements setPassword only, and linkding declared nothing at all while shipping
a full multi-user adapter, and neither mismatch had any effect.
Removed the key and its comment from all eleven configs, and replaced the stale
contract note in auth_adapter.sh with what the dispatcher really does.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Answers "should we stop creating an admin/pass on start" with the split the
catalog actually has, rather than one way for everything.
Ten apps need it: adguard, authelia, bookstack, matrix, nextcloud, owncloud,
pihole, rocketchat, stalwart, speedtest and headscale either pass the generated
password into the container or hand it to an install hook that creates the
account. There the password IS the working credential — dropping it would lock
you out. Left alone.
Three do not create an account at all: gitea, invidious and mattermost seed no
user (the first one comes from their own signup flow or the Create Account tool),
so the password minted at install named nothing. The WebUI credentials card
showed a password that could not log in. They now match linkding — an empty,
unslotted ADMIN_PASSWORD the auth adapter fills when the operator makes the first
admin, and keeps in step on later resets. Unslotted because the slot number marks
a value the installer generates.
mattermost's adapter also had linkding's bug: it persists ADMIN_PASSWORD but the
config declared only ADMIN_EMAIL, so the write was a no-op.
WebUI: rocketchat's generated admin password had no field mapping, so the card
could not show it. Added, plus a generic ADMIN_USER entry — six apps record an
admin username the card had no way to display.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Nine LONG_DESCRIPTION values had drifted well past the 90-140 char
range the rest of the catalog uses (stoat was 407). Cut them back
while keeping the caveats that matter — Rocket.Chat's user cap,
Stoat's resource weight, Matrix federation.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Rocket.Chat tails the Mongo oplog for realtime delivery, and a standalone
mongod has no oplog — so the database has to be a replica set even with one
member.
Uses the official mongo image rather than bitnami/mongodb (which upstream's own
compose uses) because Bitnami moved its catalog behind a paid registry and the
free tags are no longer dependable for a long-lived install. The cost is that
rs.initiate() is not automatic, so the post-start hook runs it once — guarded by
rs.status() so a reinstall over restored data doesn't re-initiate a live set,
and followed by a wait for the member to report itself primary.
Mongo runs without auth: enabling it on a replica set also requires a shared
keyfile for member-to-member auth, which is a lot of moving parts for a database
that is never published outside the docker network.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
